A TALE OF TWO ALPINE GEMS

Switzerland’s majestic landscapes have inspired generations to create communities that reflect excellence in architecture, social systems, and hospitality. Gstaad and St. Moritz stand out as world-renowned ski resorts, each embodying a distinct character and allure. In this “Village Test”, we will compare the two across several key criteria to offer a balanced perspective on their unique offerings.

1. Natural Beauty, Climate, and Architecture
Gstaad: 4.5/5 | St. Moritz: 3/5
Both villages boast stunning natural backdrops of snowcapped peaks, lush valleys, and crystal-clear lakes. However, their climates differ. St. Moritz’s higher altitude (1,850 m) gives it a subarctic climate, with freezing winters reaching –15°C or lower. Gstaad’s lower elevation (1,050 m) offers a milder, more temperate experience, making it more comfortable for year-round living.
When it comes to architecture, Gstaad’s traditional wooden chalets perfectly blend with the natural landscape, creating a cosy, postcard-perfect ambience. In contrast, St. Moritz’s modern high-rise hotel blocks disrupt the alpine aesthetic, which can feel incongruous with the natural surroundings.

2. History and Traditions
Gstaad: 3/5 | St. Moritz: 4.5/5
St. Moritz’s legacy as a pioneering ski resort dates back to the mid-19th century, and it’s a two-time host of the Winter Olympics (1928, 1948). The 1928 Games were groundbreaking as they marked the first time women were allowed to participate in Winter Olympic sports. The 1948 Games were the first Winter Olympics held after World War II and were also the first to be transmitted on television, though few households at the time had TV sets to witness the historic broadcast. The village’s reputation for luxury hospitality is bolstered by its famous mineral springs, which have attracted health-seekers since ancient times.
Gstaad’s rise as a vacation destination began in the early 20th century following the construction of the Montreux-Oberland railway. While Gstaad’s historical narrative is less grandiose than St. Moritz’s Olympic fame, it’s rich in authentic Swiss folklore. Events like the “Trechler” bell-ringing parade contrast with St. Moritz’s Schlitteda sleigh processions, offering equally enchanting experiences.

3. Connectivity and Transportation
Gstaad: 4/5 | St. Moritz: 3.5/5
Both villages enjoy seamless connectivity through Switzerland’s world-class transport network. St. Moritz’s journey from Zurich or Geneva takes around 4–5 hours by train or car, while Gstaad is more accessible, requiring only 3 hours. Gstaad’s proximity to major Swiss hubs gives it a clear edge.

Gstaad benefits from the nearby Saanen airport for private jet travellers, and 5 km away, St. Moritz’s Engadin airport caters to high-end clientele. The picturesque train journeys to both resorts are experiences in themselves, with Gstaad’s route from Montreux through lakes, mountains, and valleys often seen as one of the most scenic in Switzerland.

4. Hospitality, Hotels, and Administration
Gstaad: 4.5/5 | St. Moritz: 4/5
Luxury and refinement define the hospitality scene in both resorts. Gstaad’s elegant chalets and boutique hotels offer a more intimate, “village feel” experience. Meanwhile, St. Moritz’s hospitality industry is dominated by large-scale luxury hotels and grand buildings.

From an administrative perspective, Gstaad’s recent election of its first female mayor, Petra Schläppi, has been celebrated as a symbol of progress. St. Moritz’s colourful political landscape includes former actor and tenor Jott Jenny as its mayor, adding a touch of flair to local governance.

5. Sports, Health, and Education
Gstaad: 4.5/5 | St. Moritz: 4.5/5
For sports enthusiasts, both villages are a paradise. St. Moritz is home to unique activities like winter polo on its frozen lake and the Cresta Run for adrenaline-fueled tobogganing. Gstaad’s offerings are equally impressive, with annual ATP tennis tournaments and beach volleyball events that attract international audiences.

Both villages boast excellent health facilities and access to emergency services for sports-related injuries. In terms of education, Gstaad’s Le Rosey and John F. Kennedy schools have achieved worldwide renown, while St. Moritz’s Lyceum Alpinum is similarly prestigious.

6. Art and Culture
Gstaad: 4.5/5 | St. Moritz: 4.5/5
Art and culture are integral to life in both resorts. Gstaad’s Menuhin Festival draws global music lovers, while St. Moritz’s Engadin Piano Days offer a similarly rich cultural experience. Art galleries, concerts, and high-profile exhibitions are abundant in both destinations.

Famous film directors have chosen these villages as cinematic backdrops: Blake Edward’s “Pink Panther” features Gstaad’s enchanting alpine setting, while Alfred Hitchcock’s love for St. Moritz is well documented. These iconic pop-culture moments further enhance the destination’s appeal.

Final Thoughts
While Gstaad and St. Moritz each offer an unparalleled experience of Swiss luxury and natural beauty, subtle differences distinguish them. Gstaad’s charm lies in its traditional alpine character, milder climate, and village-style elegance. St. Moritz’s Olympic legacy, modern grandeur, and action-packed sports scene give it a sophisticated edge.

What makes these destinations extraordinary is their scenery and the people who live and work there. Their hospitality, innovation, and passion have turned these villages into world-class resorts. As for the etymology, both Gstaad and St. Moritz trace their names to Greek roots: St. Moritz from “Saint Mauricius”, a black saint who died in Switzerland. The name “Mauricius” comes from the Greek word “mauros”, meaning black, and Gstaad from the term istate, meaning stable or solid. Indeed, both villages are well-grounded symbols of alpine excellence.

No matter which destination you choose, rest assured you’re stepping into a world of elegance, adventure, and unforgettable beauty.

YANNIS SIATOPOULOS

Disclaimer: The author of this test is a long-standing visitor to Gstaad. While every effort has been made to remain objective, it’s possible a hint of “alpine bias” may have crept in – but hey, even the most neutral Swiss scales can tip once in a while!